Skip to Content
Skip to Menu
Skip to Footer

5 Website Optimization Tactics

To Increase Leads And Sales

Is your website optimization working hard enough to deliver the traffic, conversions, and user experience you crave? If your website is underperforming, it's like leaving money on the table, but you're not alone.

Toolbox No. 9 is here to change that. We specialize in data-driven website optimization strategies that get you noticed, drive qualified leads, and boost your bottom line.

Drawing on over 15 years of experience working on hundreds of marketing products, here are 5 tactics by Toolbox No. 9 to significantly improve your engagement and conversion metrics.

We specialize in finding the fastest, most effective ways to improve your website's performance without scraping it entirely.

94% of companies experienced a rise in conversion rates after personalizing their websites.
There can be a 10 to 15% increase in revenue due to personalization.

1. Target the Right Audience for Maximum Results

94% of companies experienced a rise in conversion rates after personalizing their websites.(*) Instead of focusing on what you do, focus on who you benefit. The more personalized the experience for visitors, the higher the engagement. This can be achieved by delivering the right content to the right visitor at the right time in their journey.

Audience-specific content pathways are tailored content journeys created for specific profiles, addressing their unique needs, motivators, and goals through a series of landing pages and content tunnels.

On average, there can be a 10% to 15% increase in revenue due to personalization.(*) Start with these steps to deeply understand and target your ideal customers:

  • Define audience profiles: The first step is to clearly determine the specific target audience's goals, motivations, and pain points through a proper Customer Journey Workshop. Let's say you're a marketing automation software company. One audience profile might be "Marketing Managers in SaaS companies." Their goals could include increasing lead generation, their pain points might be a lack of time and resources, and their motivations could involve finding efficient ways to nurture leads.

    With a clearer picture of your audience in mind, you can now:
  • Incorporate audience terminology into existing content. Modify existing landing pages using your audience's language and addressing their specific needs. For instance, research and utilize terms familiar to your target audience. Create content that speaks directly to visitors instead of using your own internal terminology.Instead of a generic headline like "Improve Your Marketing Results," consider "SaaS Marketing Managers: Streamline Lead Nurturing and Boost Conversions." This directly addresses a pain point and uses industry-specific language.

    Additionally, to truly connect with your audience:
  • Create custom audience landers and content paths: Define the minimal content needed for each audience and incorporate it into specific pages generated for them. Determine the most significant motivators and pain points for different audiences and incorporate them into calls-to-action, headers, and body content.

    A landing page for the "SaaS Marketing Manager" doesn't need to explain the basics of marketing automation. Instead, focus on benefits like time savings, lead scoring features, and integration capabilities that resonate with them.

    This targeted approach leads to higher engagement, better conversions, and a more personalized customer experience.

    The top benefits of personalization include increased visitor engagement (55%), improved customer experience (55%), improved brand perception (39%), increased conversion rates (51%) and increased lead generation and customer acquisition (46%) (

2. The Power of Visuals for Engagement And Website Optimization

Evolutionarily, our brains prioritize visual information, which explains why we retain 65% of visually paired content compared to just 10% of text alone.

That is why incorporating relevant images, infographics, and videos into your website can be a powerful tool for driving traffic, increasing engagement, and improving the user experience. This offers a more enjoyable experience for your customers, leading to higher satisfaction and return visits. Additionally, when your visual style is consistent across all your content, this reinforces your brand identity and makes your company more recognizable.

  • Infographics can increase website traffic by up to 12%. (*)
  • Infographics are 30 times more likely to be read than a written article. (*)

Ready to level up your content? Visuals are the key! Here are a few powerful ways to get started:

  • Static Visuals: Even simple additions boost engagement. You can use editable stock resources like istockphoto.com, which offers a comprehensive collection of affordable illustrations. Adding a few visuals can also help break up text-heavy pages and make your content more digestible.
  • Infographic Storytelling: Infographics are a popular visual content format that can be used to tell a story or illustrate complex data. By presenting information in a visual format and using data visualizations, you can make it easier for your audience to understand and engage with your content. Consider using infographic storytelling to convey important information about your brand or product in a fun and memorable way.  

    Toolbox No. 9 has measured our client’s engagement time on page increases of 2–10x with the incorporation of infographic content. 
  • Video & Animation: Creating short, informative videos or animations is a great way to bring your content to life and keep your audience engaged. Videos and animations can be used to explain a product or service, or to showcase your brand in a powerful way. Whether you choose Whether you create your own videos or hire a professional, this type of visual content can be a valuable tool for engaging your audience.

    Video drives impressive results.
    Renderforest's survey reveals that users who utilize video content experience a 78% traffic increase, 83% longer visit durations, 83% more leads generated, and a 44% sales increase.
Infographics can increase website traffic by up to 12%
Infographics are 30 times more likely to be read than a written article.
Visually appealing CTAs can increase click-through rates by up to 42%

3. Upgrade Your CTAs for Better Conversions

CTAs need great website usability to truly shine. If you want effortlessly to guide your visitors toward desired actions, prioritize clear layouts, easy navigation, and eye-catching CTAs to achieve this goal.

This powerful combination increases conversions and leaves users satisfied with their website experience.

Upgrading your call-to-actions (CTAs) is one of the easiest and most effective ways to improve your website's optimization.

For instance, a simple CTA tweak—from "Book a Demo" to "Get Started"—more than doubled PartnerStack's conversion rate (+111.55%).Want your CTAs to drive action? Here's how to make them irresistible:

  • Visually Identifiable: Ensure that your CTAs stand out by providing adequate margin and color contrast with the background. This can make your CTAs more visible and easy to find for your visitors. Visually appealing CTAs can increase click-through rates by up to 42% (*)
  • Motivating Messaging: Use specific, urgent, motivating, non-committal, and personalized messaging that speaks directly to your target audience. Use a button or link label that starts with a verb to indicate action and encourage visitors to take the desired action.

    In an experiment by
    CXL, a simple CTA tweak—adding "now" and a countdown timer—boosted conversions by an impressive 147%! This highlights the power of FOMO marketing in action.
  • Personalized: Want to boost conversions and create a better website experience? Focus on your CTAs! Make them easy to find, action-driven, and personalized for powerful results.

    According to a
    study by HubSpot, personalized CTAs can lead to a potential increase in conversion rates of up to 202%.

    To learn more about how to improve your CTAs, check out this collection of
    A/B split tests.

4. Consistent Messaging for Campaign Success

Inconsistent messaging across channels is a common culprit for high bounce rates and missed conversions. 

At Toolbox, we've seen clients achieve up to a 500% improvement in campaign performance simply by ensuring a seamless message match from ads and social posts to landing pages.

Here are some steps you can take to create a consistent customer journey:

Fine-Tune Your Paid and Social for Maximum Impact
Before digging into creative changes, ensure the basics are solid:

  • Landing Page Matching: Do your ads and social posts lead to the most relevant landing page for that specific offer (demo, free trial, etc.)?
  • Consistency Check: Do the headlines and CTAs on your ads accurately mirror what visitors find on the landing page? Even small mismatches hurt conversion rates.

Your potential customers want to feel understood; start by making sure every click delivers on the initial promise.

Don't send everyone to the same generic page

Craft unique landing pages tailored to each paid or social campaign. This personalized approach ensures that the message and offer match what visitors expect when they click your ad or post. By delivering a relevant experience, you'll increase engagement, boost conversions, and maximize the return on your marketing investments.

Here's a breakdown of why this approach is so effective:

  • Relevancy: When visitors click on an ad or social post, they have specific expectations based on what they just saw.
  • Targeted Messaging: Generic landing pages often try to appeal to everyone, resulting in watered-down messages. Unique landing pages deliver laser-focused messaging that speaks directly to the specific interests and needs of your target audience.
  • Increased Conversions: By delivering exactly what visitors expect and providing a clear path to the desired action, you significantly increase the chances of them converting (signing up, making a purchase, etc.).
  • Better Data Tracking: When each campaign has its own dedicated landing page, it's much easier to track its performance and attribute success accurately. You can see which campaigns are working best and optimize accordingly.

Companies with over 30 landing pages generate 7 times more leads than those with fewer than 10. (*)

Once visitors land, make the path to conversion crystal clear. Ensure your CTAs and forms match the promises made in your ads or social posts. If you're offering a free trial, for example, your button should say, "Start Your Free Trial Now!" 

Remind visitors of the value they'll receive, making it effortless for them to take that final step.

Want to fine-tune your results even further? 

Experiment with different versions of your landing pages and CTAs through A/B testing. This reveals what truly resonates with your audience. By continuously testing and tweaking, you'll discover the highest-performing combinations, leading to a more effective and consistent customer journey.

Don't leave your campaign success to chance. Let Toolbox No. 9's A/B testing experts guide you to a website that converts like never before.

Achieve up to a 500% improvement in campaign performance simply by ensuring a seamless message match from ads and social posts to landing pages.
68% of online experiences begin with a search engine.

5. Technical SEO Optimization for Visitors and Search Engines

Even without a complete website overhaul, you can significantly improve your site's performance for both visitors and search engines. By focusing on a few key areas, you can enhance the user experience, increase search visibility, and ultimately drive more leads.

Keep these two factors in mind when considering website optimization, including user accessibility:

  • Performance for Visitors: Studies show that a one-second delay in page load time can decrease conversions by 7%. *Reducing mobile site speed by 0.1 seconds results in an 8% increase in conversions (*)By optimizing for Core Web Vitals, you can significantly reduce bounce rates and increase the likelihood of visitors staying on your site, exploring your content, and ultimately becoming customers.
  • Performance for SEO: Common issues like slow-loading images, render-blocking resources, and excessive JavaScript can negatively impact both the user experience and search engine rankings. A technical SEO audit can identify these problems and provide solutions to optimize your website's performance.

    68% of online experiences begin with a search engine. (
    63.41% of all US web traffic referrals come from Google. (
    92.96% of global traffic comes from Google Search, Google Images, and Google Maps. (
    SEO drives 1,000%+ more traffic than organic social media. (

To get started, we recommend evaluating your site.

  • Page Insights: To see how Google measures your site, test it on https://pagespeed.web.dev/. Page Insights will provide some helpful technical information on how to potentially improve your website.
  • Responsive Testing: With more and more users accessing the internet on mobile devices, responsive design is no longer a luxury but a necessity. A mobile-friendly website ensures a seamless experience for all users, regardless of their device. Additionally, Google now uses mobile-first indexing, meaning it primarily crawls and indexes the mobile version of your website.

A focus on website optimization can lead to better business outcomes, such as:

  • Increased website visits
  • Improved click-through rates
  • Higher engagement time 
  • Decreased bounce rates
  • Increased conversion rates
  •  Improved customer experience
  • Faster website performance
  • Improved SEO rankings

Mastering website optimization isn't about a single magic trick—it's about wielding a toolkit of strategic tactics. By understanding your audience, crafting compelling visuals, optimizing your calls to action, ensuring consistent messaging, and addressing SEO, you can unlock your website's full potential.As already mentioned, website optimization isn't a one-and-done deal. It's an ongoing process that requires continuous monitoring, testing, and refining. But the rewards are undeniable: increased traffic, higher conversions, an improved user experience, and ultimately, an online presence that drives real business results.

Are you ready to transform your website into a high-performing asset?

How can Toolbox help you launch your next big idea?

Contact us today, or select a date and time when we can meet.


Toolbox No. 9 (Band of Coders)
1643 Mount Vernon Rd.
Dunwoody, GA 30338
Contact Us